Friday, December 2, 2011

Critique Teen Sex Education Debate Commentary by Christina Resas

    
October 26, 2011, Classmate blog http://christinaresas,blospot.com/teensexeducationdebate, the article is commentary from Austin American Statesman. Christina, states that after reading the article, she questions whether or not sex education should or should not be taught in Texas. In the United States when it comes to sex education it is required that students learn about HIV/STD’s. That in the states where it is taught abstinence is not a requirement. Texas schools are not require to teach sex education classes unless the school district chooses too, and if they do offer sex education classes, they are required to teach abstinence.
     The National Center for Health Statistics studies that stated sine the late 1980’s there is a decline in teens that are sexually active. Female have dropped from 51% to 43%, for males a drop from 60% to 42%. As of 1988 the apparent use of contraception has increased, during the last 20 years. The article states both sides to the argument…discusses contraception promotion. So in a sense the article was contradicting itself. So in the end has sex decreased among teen? If so why does there seem to be more teens having babies? Why the bigger and stronger push on condoms? 
     Christina take on the subject come from a place of great passion. Christina personal taken on the subject and I quote “this is just crazy too me! I would say that if anything within the past 20 years, our population has sky rocketed! And she feels that the birth rate is ridiculous. “I’m seeing babies having babies; I think all these young girls just need abstinence education.” I can hear in her writing, the conflict, disappointment, and also the conviction on the choices provide to our future generation of adults.  She has a legitimate concern about the promotion of contraceptive and the message translated by plan parenthood clinics. I must that I agree with Christina, but I must add not just in Texas be in the whole of the United States, sex education should be required. But I disagree that they should solely teach abstinence. She stated, “Its common sense to know what is going to happen, if you don’t protect yourself, but the entire happy looking condom commercials, all the spunky plan parenthood workers handing out condoms left and right… is just not promoting any thing positive.” I don’t feel that sex education is solely about protection. Children are that children, they need to be taught and given a clear understanding, about what having sex means, the consequences, and shown example of the true outcome. This was a good topic and her passionate inputs add interest to the piece. Some grammar changes needed, and I enjoyed it, personal passion always gives an article more depth.

No comments:

Post a Comment